Second-hand handsets: pay GST on your margin, not the whole price
Rule 32(5) lets a dealer in used goods tax only the difference between what they paid and what they sold for. On a ₹12,000 resale bought at ₹10,000 that is the difference between ₹360 of tax and ₹2,160.
- Written by
- Gurpreet Kait
- Written for
- Shops that buy used handsets from walk-in customers and resell them
- Facts checked
- 22 Oct 2026
- Sources
- 5, 2 primary
A customer sells you their old handset for ₹10,000. You clean it up and sell it for ₹12,000. If you charge 18% on ₹12,000 you owe ₹2,160 of tax on a ₹2,000 gross margin, which is obviously absurd — you would be paying more in tax than you made.
The rules anticipate this. Rule 32(5) of the CGST Rules gives dealers in second-hand goods a margin scheme: the value of supply is the difference between the purchase price and the selling price, and that difference is what you tax.
How much GST does the margin scheme save on a used phone?
| Tax on full value | Tax on margin — Rule 32(5) | |
|---|---|---|
| You bought it for | ₹10,000 | ₹10,000 |
| You sold it for | ₹12,000 | ₹12,000 |
| Value of supply | ₹12,000 | ₹2,000 |
| GST at 18% | ₹2,160 | ₹360 |
| Left in your pocket from a ₹2,000 margin | −₹160 | ₹1,640 |
Two further details of the rule matter at the counter:
- A negative margin is ignored. Sell at a loss and the value is nil — you do not get a credit out of it, but you do not pay tax on a loss either.
- Each unit stands alone. The margin is worked out per handset, not netted across a month's trade. A ₹3,000 gain on one and a ₹1,000 loss on another is ₹3,000 of taxable margin, not ₹2,000.
When can you use the margin scheme?
The scheme is a trade, and the price of admission is that you cannot have claimed input tax credit on buying the handset. That is a precondition written into Rule 32(5), not an optional extra.
How is a trade-in against a new phone taxed?
The margin scheme deals cleanly with the resale of a used handset. The common Indian counter transaction is messier: the customer's old phone comes in as part-payment for a new one, on the same bill.
There are really two supplies in that moment — you supplying a new handset, and the customer supplying you an old one — with part of the price settled in goods rather than cash. GST on the new handset is charged on its full value, not the net cash the customer hands over. Reducing the taxable value of the new phone by the trade-in allowance is a mistake that overstates nothing and understates your output tax.
What records does the margin scheme need?
The margin scheme only works if you can prove the margin, which means proving the purchase price of that specific handset — months later, to someone who does not take your word for it. Per-unit records are not optional here, they are the whole basis of the claim.
- What you paid, against the IMEI. Not "used phones, ₹40,000" for a batch. The individual unit, with the individual price, because the margin is computed per unit.
- Who you bought it from, with identity details and ideally a signed declaration that the handset is theirs to sell. This protects you on the stolen-goods question as much as the tax one.
- The IMEI check you ran before paying — see the IMEI rules post for why a blocked handset makes all of this moot.
- The condition it came in, so a later dispute about what you sold has something behind it.
Rule 32(5) is long-standing and uncontroversial, and the sources below are secondary for it. The part-exchange question is now answered from the Rules themselves — Rule 27 and its illustration — rather than left open. Refurbishment remains genuinely unsettled rather than merely unresearched. Checked 22 October 2026.
Sources
Checked on 22 Oct 2026. Government text is marked primary; everything else is somebody explaining it, and is marked as such. GST and telecom rules change often — confirm anything you are about to act on.
- secondaryTaxAdda — GST on purchase and sale of second-hand goods under the margin scheme, Rule 32(5)
- secondaryTax2win — margin scheme under GST: applicability and conditions
- secondaryTaxHandout — GST on second-hand goods and the mechanics of Rule 32(5)
- primaryCGST Rules, Rule 27 — value of supply where the consideration is not wholly in money, with the phone-exchange illustration
- primaryCBIC — GST goods and services rate finder, for the rate applying to the handset itself
Read next
The IMEI rules an Indian phone shop is actually bound by
Three years in jail for tampering, a registration duty that falls on importers and not on you, a database you are expected to check before buying a used handset — and no law anywhere requiring an IMEI on your invoice.
Read itGSTGST rates and HSN codes for everything in a phone shop
Handsets, chargers, earbuds, tempered glass, spare displays and repair labour — the rate and the code for each, why 12% and 28% no longer exist, and how to tax a repair bill that has both a part and labour on it.
Read it